The short answer
If you own a flat in one of Edinburgh's tenements – in Marchmont, Bruntsfield, Leith, Gorgie, Newington, Stockbridge or the New Town – the roof, the outside walls, the foundations and usually the stair are shared. Nobody can leave the roof to the top-floor flat or the stonework to whoever's window is leaking. Repairs are paid for by all the owners together.
How the bill is split depends first on your title deeds. Where the deeds don't cover something, the Tenement Management Scheme in the Tenements (Scotland) Act 2004 fills the gap: a majority of owners can make decisions about repairs, and the costs are shared equally between the flats – or by floor area if the biggest flat is more than one and a half times the size of the smallest.
Most Edinburgh tenements don't have a property factor, so owners have to organise repairs themselves. The City of Edinburgh Council's Edinburgh Shared Repairs Service gives free advice, and its Missing Shares Service can pay the share of an owner who won't or can't pay, then recover it from them.
This guide explains who owns what, how to make a decision with your neighbours, how to split the cost fairly, the extra rules for Edinburgh's listed buildings and conservation areas, and how to find good roofers, builders and stonemasons. It's general information, not legal advice – for a dispute or a large bill, speak to a solicitor or to Under One Roof, Scotland's tenement charity. Every source is listed at the bottom of the page.
Who owns what in an Edinburgh tenement
Edinburgh has one of the biggest concentrations of tenement flats in Europe. Many are 19th-century sandstone buildings, four or five storeys high, with a common stair (the "close") and a pitched slate roof with chimney stacks, skews and gutters. Others are early 20th-century or later blocks.
The basic rule is simple: the title deeds decide. Most older Edinburgh deeds make the roof, the outside walls, the foundations, the main structure, the close and the back green common property of all the owners.
If the deeds don't say, the Tenements (Scotland) Act 2004 sets out default rules. In general:
| Part of the building | Who usually owns it (if deeds are silent) |
|---|---|
| Roof | The top-floor flat(s) – but it's still "scheme property", so everyone shares the cost of maintaining it |
| Roof over the close | All owners who use the close |
| Outside walls | The owner of the flat they enclose, to the middle of the wall |
| Foundations / solum | The ground-floor flat(s) |
| Common stair (close) | The owners of the flats it serves |
| Chimney stacks | Shared by the flats they serve |
The important point is that ownership and paying for repairs are not the same thing. Even if the Act says the top-floor flat owns the roof, the roof, outside walls, foundations and load-bearing walls are all "scheme property" under the Tenement Management Scheme. That means every owner shares the cost of maintaining them.
The Tenement Management Scheme in plain English
The Tenement Management Scheme (TMS) is a set of rules that applies to every tenement in Scotland unless the title deeds already cover the same thing. It explains:
- what counts as scheme property (the parts every owner must help maintain)
- how owners make scheme decisions
- how costs are shared
Making a decision
Under the TMS, each flat gets one vote, and decisions are made by a majority of all the votes – not just the people who turn up. In an eight-flat stair, five owners need to agree. You can vote at a meeting or by contacting each owner, as long as everyone is given a fair chance to have their say. Owners who were outvoted or not consulted can ask the sheriff court to cancel a decision within 28 days.
A majority can decide, for example, to:
- carry out maintenance or repairs to scheme property
- appoint a contractor or a manager (a factor)
- arrange an inspection of the building
- ask every owner to pay a deposit into a maintenance account before work starts
- install a door entry system
Splitting the cost
Unless the deeds say otherwise, the TMS shares the cost of maintaining scheme property equally between the flats. The exception is when the floor area of the biggest flat is more than one and a half times the smallest. Then repair costs are split by floor area instead – so the owner of a large main-door flat or a double upper may pay more than a one-bedroom flat in the attic. Costs like inspections, management fees and door entry systems are always shared equally.
Emergencies
If something needs fixing urgently to stop damage to the building or a danger to health or safety – a burst pipe in the close, a chimney about to fall, a big leak through the roof – any owner can instruct emergency work without waiting for a vote. The other owners then have to pay their share. Keep it to what's truly urgent, and keep the receipts.
Selling a flat
If you sell, you're still liable for your share of repairs decided before you sold, and the new owner can be liable too. That's why buyers' solicitors ask about planned common repairs, and why our moving house checklist suggests asking the seller about the state of the roof and stonework.
Stonework, lime and listed buildings
Edinburgh is built from sandstone. Over time, rain, frost and pollution wear it away – the face of the stone flakes (spalling), joints open up, and decorative details like window sills, cornices and string courses crack.
Use the right materials
Many older tenements were built with soft lime mortar. Repointing with hard cement mortar can trap moisture in the stone and make it decay faster. Historic Environment Scotland advises using lime-based mortars on traditional buildings, and many Edinburgh stonemasons specialise in this work. Ask any contractor what mortar they'll use and why.
Listed buildings and conservation areas
Much of central Edinburgh is in the Old and New Towns World Heritage Site, and large parts of the city are conservation areas with thousands of listed buildings. That matters for repairs:
- Like-for-like repairs – same materials, same appearance – usually don't need consent.
- Changes – different stone, cement instead of lime, new windows of a different design, removing chimneys, changing roof materials – may need listed building consent or planning permission from the Council.
- Doing work without consent can lead to enforcement action, so check before you start.
A good contractor who works on Edinburgh's older buildings will know when consent is needed. If you're not sure, ask the Council's planning department before signing a contract.
Windows
Sash and case windows belong to each flat owner, not the whole tenement – but in listed buildings and some conservation areas, replacing them with uPVC or a different style needs permission. Many window and door fitters in the city offer sash window repair and draught-proofing as an alternative to replacement.
Factors: when you have one, and when you don't
Unlike Glasgow, where most tenements have a property factor, many Edinburgh tenements are unfactored. That means the owners organise everything themselves. Some owners decide by majority to appoint a factor to handle repairs, insurance and cleaning. Factors must be on the Scottish property factor register and follow a code of conduct. If you're in Glasgow, our guide to Glasgow tenements covers factors in more detail.
Even without a factor, it helps to have:
- one owner who acts as the contact person for each project
- a simple owners' association, with a short written agreement about how decisions are made
- a maintenance account where owners pay a small amount every month towards future repairs
Coming changes: owners' associations, inspections and reserve funds
Scotland's tenement repair problem is well known. A Scottish Parliament working group recommended three big reforms:
- compulsory owners' associations for every tenement
- building inspections every five years
- building reserve funds, so owners save towards repairs
In December 2025 the Scottish Law Commission published its report on compulsory owners' associations, with a draft Tenements (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill. Several parties made commitments on tenement reform before the 2026 Scottish Parliament election. At the time of writing these are proposals, not law – check Under One Roof or the Scottish Government for the latest. Setting up a voluntary owners' association and a reserve fund now puts your building ahead of any changes.
Which trade to call
| Job | Who to call |
|---|---|
| Slates, leadwork, gutters, chimney pots | A roofer with tenement experience |
| Stonework, repointing, chimney stacks | A stonemason or builder who works with lime |
| Sash windows | A joiner or carpenter, or a window specialist |
| Close lighting, door entry systems | An electrician |
| Leaking pipes in the close, water tanks in the roof space | A plumber |
| Close decoration | A painter and decorator |
| Stair cleaning | A cleaning company |
Our listings cover the whole of Edinburgh, split by neighbourhood, so you can look for firms close to your stair.
How to choose a contractor for tenement work
Shared repairs often involve big sums and several owners, so it's worth taking care. Our guide on how to choose a builder goes into detail, but for tenement work in particular:
- Choose firms with experience of Edinburgh tenements and traditional stone buildings.
- Get at least two written quotes based on the same specification.
- Ask for photos of the problem before and after, especially for roof work nobody can see.
- Check insurance – public liability and, for bigger jobs, employer's liability.
- Ask whether scaffolding, skips, permits and making good are included.
- Ask about lime mortar and whether listed building consent is needed.
- Agree payment stages – never pay the full amount up front.
- Ask about guarantees and keep them with your property papers.
Examples: three Edinburgh tenements
These are illustrative examples, not quotes.
A six-flat stair in Marchmont with a leaking roof. Water is coming into the top-floor flat. One owner gets two quotes for repairing slates, leadwork and the gutters, including scaffolding. Five of the six owners agree by email – a majority – and each pays one-sixth into a shared account before work starts. The sixth owner, a landlord abroad, ignores the letters, so the owners apply to the Missing Shares Service.
A New Town tenement with crumbling stonework. A cornice is cracking and a piece has fallen onto the pavement. The Council makes the area safe, and the owners get a survey through the Shared Repairs Service. The repair needs matching sandstone and lime mortar, so the owners choose a specialist stonemason. Costs are split by floor area, because the main-door flat is more than twice the size of the attic flat.
A Leith block with no factor. After a bad winter, the owners set up a simple owners' association, agree to pay £20 a month each into a maintenance account, and book a roof inspection every two years. Small repairs are now paid from the account without arguments.
Finding roofers and builders near you
Search our roofers and builders for firms near your stair. If you're comparing advice with friends elsewhere in Scotland, look at Glasgow and Aberdeen too – tenements there face many of the same problems, although the rules on factors are often different.
Frequently asked questions
Who pays for a tenement roof repair in Edinburgh?
Usually all the owners in the building. Check the title deeds first. If they don't say, the Tenement Management Scheme treats the roof as scheme property, so the cost is shared equally between the flats, or by floor area if the biggest flat is more than one and a half times the smallest.
Can a majority of owners force a repair?
Yes. Under the Tenement Management Scheme, a majority of all the flats (one vote per flat) can make a scheme decision to carry out repairs, and every owner then has to pay their share. Owners can challenge a decision in the sheriff court within 28 days.
What if one owner won't pay?
The City of Edinburgh Council's Missing Shares Service can pay the missing owner's share, as long as you've followed the correct steps, and then recover the money from them. You can also take court action yourselves.
Do I need permission to repair stonework in Edinburgh?
Like-for-like repairs usually don't. Changes to a listed building or a building in a conservation area – such as using different materials or replacing windows with a different design – may need listed building consent or planning permission. Check with the Council if you're not sure.
Does the top-floor flat have to pay for the roof?
Not on their own, in most cases. Even where the top-floor owner technically owns the roof, the Tenement Management Scheme makes the roof's maintenance a shared cost.
What is the Edinburgh Shared Repairs Service?
It's a free Council service for private owners that gives advice on shared repairs, offers a tenement toolkit and building survey service, and runs the Missing Shares Service.
Are owners' associations compulsory in Scotland?
Not yet. The Scottish Law Commission recommended compulsory owners' associations in December 2025, alongside five-yearly inspections and reserve funds, but these need new legislation. Check for the latest position.
Should repointing on an Edinburgh tenement use lime?
On traditional stone tenements, usually yes. Hard cement mortar can trap moisture and damage sandstone. Ask your stonemason or builder what they recommend and why.
Sources
- City of Edinburgh Council – Shared repairs and maintenance (Edinburgh Shared Repairs Service; free advice; tenement toolkit; Missing Shares Service)
- City of Edinburgh Council – Missing Shares Service factsheet (when the Council can pay a missing share)
- City of Edinburgh Council – Building survey service factsheet (survey with estimated cost of repairs)
- mygov.scot – Tenement Management Scheme (scheme decisions; equal shares; one-and-a-half times floor area exception)
- Tenements (Scotland) Act 2004 – Schedule 1, Rule 4 (scheme costs and how they're shared)
- Tenements (Scotland) Act 2004 – Explanatory notes on Rule 4 (majority decisions; floor area rule)
- Shelter Scotland – Cost of repairs (roof and external walls shared equally; floor area exception)
- Scottish Law Commission – Tenement law: compulsory owners' associations (report and draft Bill published 11 December 2025)
- Scottish Housing News – Four major parties make manifesto commitments on tenement reform (owners' associations, five-yearly inspections, reserve funds)
- Cockburn Association – Care and repair in Edinburgh's private rental sector (shared roofs, gutters and stonework; Missing Shares Service)
- Under One Roof – Scotland's tenement charity (impartial advice for flat owners in Scotland)